Review for: The Winnowing Season [Amish Vines and Orchards series Book2] by Cindy Woodsmall

Amish couple in a horse-drawn buggy in rural H...

Amish couple in a horse-drawn buggy in rural Holmes County (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

The Winnowing Season [Amish Vines and Orchards series Book 2] by Cindy Woodsmall

A written review of the first book can be found here.

After a tornado ripped through King’s Orchards, owners and business partners Samuel, Jacob and Eli King and Rhoda Byler decide to purchase an abandoned orchard in Maine to restore, and give the damaged orchard time to recover. To do that, a new Amish community needed be established around the orchard. There were no other Amish in Maine. Several families purchased the orchard together and prepare to move to Maine. Samuel and Jacob King have gone with their sister Leah, along with Rhoda and her brother Steven’s family, and Rhoda’s business assistant Landon. They began restoring the farmhouse and the orchards while waiting for two other families to join them later.

English: An old apple orchard in Ottawa, Canada.

English: An old apple orchard in Ottawa, Canada. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

However, before they even arrived in Maine, complications overtook them. Jacob, who was courting Rhoda, was called away suddenly, and was unable to explain why because he was still keeping secrets from her. Samuel was being unbearably rude to Rhoda to keep his distance, although Rhoda didn’t know why he was treating her so coldly. Landon was attracted to Leah, but felt conflicted because even though he knew Leah wanted to leave the Amish, she hadn’t told her brothers yet and Landon did not want to get into trouble with Rhoda, his boss. Once they arrived in Maine, they had no heat in the house or cooking fuel. Delivery of the cattle that were in Steven’s care was delayed. So on the first night in the farmhouse, the children and women were alone and the men were absent.

Only a few weeks later Rhoda found some teenage girls camping in one of the greenhouses. She gave them a firm but kind warning to leave and she would not report them to the police. But a short time later police arrived at the farmhouse and informed Rhoda she was being investigated for possession of drugs, thanks to accusations from one of the girls’ parents, the wife of a US senator. With police trudging in and out of her greenhouses, confiscating her seedlings and new plants, their containers and things in her room, orchard and garden development was delayed. And Jacob, who had finally arrived after the first personal crisis had to leave again, to stay away from the press and the police again, due to secrets he was harboring. Tensions were high at the new settlement.

In addition to the disturbing circumstances, Rhoda realized that the problems she had in the community where she grew up weren’t left behind as she had hoped. When she befriended an older couple who lived nearby, a non-Amish couple, she began receiving flashes of insight, voices and intuition that something was wrong or unresolved. But unlike her previous experiences, she did not tell anyone about her insights, even when she realized in a flash of intuition that Jacob had been with another woman when he was away.

Orchard in winter

Orchard in winter (Photo credit: Arlette)

With all the trials besetting the residents of the new Maine Amish community, came spiritual growth. Many of the residents searched within themselves, turning to God and each other for the comfort, renewal and strength they needed to meet so many challenges. There’s room for a multitude of small victories in the private lives of our characters, but the final scenes leave the reader in suspense. The police investigation ended well, but resulted in the loss of the two investing families when they decided not to join the small group in Maine. Jacob returned home but broke his courtship with Rhoda, who has decided to stay with her friends nearby to recover from the loss. The future of the orchard hangs in the balance. We must wait for book three in the series to find what will become of the new Amish community.

The draw for me in this series is the personal journeys each character has embarked. The setbacks they experienced were merely surface problems compared to the inner struggles suffered by ones I, as a reader, had come to care about. The author skillfully crafted a world where I’ve felt comfortable, and people I empathize with. When reading this story, I feel as if I were coming along side of a friend, to listen to their fears and indecision, or to be the sounding board when they question decisions they had already made. Some were disheartened and discouraged. Relationships were strained, especially between Samuel and Rhoda. Landon felt conflicted about keeping his relationships with Leah and Rhoda balanced. Rhoda even wondered if she attracted trouble wherever she went. Without Rhoda’s expertise in horticultural arts, the new orchard was doomed to fail if she didn’t help the Kings. But was all the strain worth it?

A complimentary review copy was provided to me by the Edelweiss website which services WaterBrook Press . I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own.

Related articles

Powered by Linky Tools

Click here to enter your link and view this Linky Tools list…


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s